Firm Wins Appeal in Decades-Old Priest Sexual Abuse Case

Serving Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, New York & Nationwide

Persistence. It is what makes winning cases, and winning law firms.

This case involved alleged sexual abuse by a priest that occurred in 1971. The victim was 14 years old when a priest from the Archdiocese of Philadelphia took the child overnight to the beach, to a house in Margate City, N.J.

Once there, the boy, named only as T.D. in a lawsuit, was plied with alcohol, shown pornography, and sexually assaulted. Assaults continued over the next several months after the teenager was returned to Pennsylvania. The priest, Michael McCarthy, was accused of also having taken other teenage boys from the Archdiocese of Philadelphia on overnight trips to the Jersey Shore. He was defrocked in 2005.

Although the alleged crimes occurred decades ago, civil suits were permitted under new legislation that created a “window” during which victims of sexual abuse may bring claims against their abusers and the Catholic Church.

Kline & Specter attorneys filed such a suit in the T.D. case in New Jersey against not only the priest but also the Archdiocese of Philadelphia.

The archdiocese sought to have the case dismissed on a claim that New Jersey courts lacked the jurisdiction to decide the matter and that the archdiocese was not responsible for the actions of McCarthy for jurisdictional purposes because his actions fell beyond the scope of his employment. And the archdiocese won those claims, with New Jersey Superior Court, Law Division, dismissing the suit.

But the plaintiff’s attorneys appealed, arguing that jurisdiction was proper and that the Archdiocese of Philadelphia was a responsible party, opining that the priest was able to take the child unsupervised because of his employment with the archdiocese and the trust associated with his office.

Recently, the Appellate Division of the New Jersey Superior Court vacated the lower court’s dismissal order and remanded the case for further jurisdictional discovery. The lawsuit, thus, will continue, even though the alleged abuse occurred nearly 50 years ago and McCarthy is now 83 years old.

“We are heartened by the Appellate Division’s decision to vacate the underlying order and remand for discovery on the archdiocese’s responsibility for the actions of the archdiocesan priest who abused T.D. during a relationship created within the pastoral and counseling work that was part of the priest’s job. The archdiocese should be found responsible for its agent’s actions for jurisdictional purposes, the same as for liability purposes,” said Kline & Specter’s David Inscho, lead attorney for the plaintiff.

In a previous case, Inscho worked with Tom Kline to achieve the largest-ever settlement against the Philadelphia archdiocese in a case involving the sexual abuse of a child by a pedophile priest. The settlement amount was confidential.

Learn more about sexual abuse by priests and what you or a loved one can do if victimized by a member of the clergy.

“The most powerful
plaintiffs firm in the city”

- Philadelphia Business Journal

superlawyers color (1)
innercircle color (1)

We have an unmatched staff of five doctor-lawyers working full-time for our firm. No other law firm in the United States has as many physicians on staff.

We work closely with you to help ensure you receive every bit of legal, medical, insurance and financial assistance to which you are entitled.

We care about making things right. In a lot of cases, that means getting you more than just money. Our cases have resulted in safety improvements in medical care, consumer products, mass transit, motor vehicles, public utilities, police conduct and more.

We provide free case reviews and we work on a contingent fee basis, meaning we don’t get paid unless you win.

"*" indicates required fields

Address
Agreement
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Latest News

Top OSHA Violations in the Construction Industry

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, around one in five worker deaths happen in the construction field. Many of these tragedies are preventable and often tied to violations of basic ...
Read More

How Delayed Cesarean Sections Can Cause Birth Injuries

Labor doesn't always go as planned. When complications arise, a cesarean section (C-section) can mean the difference between a healthy delivery and serious harm.  What happens when that decision comes ...
Read More

Join Our Mailing List

"*" indicates required fields

Your Full Name*
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.