When you seek medical care, you trust that the doctor or health care professional examining you will identify what is wrong and set you on the correct course of treatment. When that process fails and a condition is identified incorrectly, diagnosed too late, or missed entirely, the consequences can be serious and maybe even permanent.
An estimated six million cases of missed or misdiagnosis resulting in patient harm occur each year in the United States. If a misdiagnosis injured you or a family member in the Philadelphia area, a Philadelphia misdiagnosis lawyer at Kline & Specter can evaluate whether the circumstances support a medical malpractice claim.
What Is Medical Misdiagnosis?
Medical misdiagnosis is a broad term that encompasses several distinct types of diagnostic failure. Each can delay or prevent appropriate treatment and may have serious consequences for a patient’s health and prognosis, depending on the condition involved.
Misdiagnosis (Wrong Diagnosis)
A misdiagnosis occurs when a doctor identifies a patient’s condition as something other than what it actually is. The patient may receive treatment for the wrong condition, which is at best ineffective and at worst harmful, while the actual medical problem goes unaddressed and potentially worsens.
Delayed Diagnosis
A delayed diagnosis occurs when a doctor eventually reaches the correct conclusion, but only after an unreasonable amount of time has passed. For conditions where early intervention affects outcomes, like cancers, strokes, or infections, a delay in reaching the correct diagnosis may significantly affect a patient’s prognosis and treatment options.
Failure to Diagnose (Missed Diagnosis)
A missed diagnosis occurs when a doctor fails to identify a condition at all, despite the presence of symptoms that warranted further evaluation. Rather than being directed toward the wrong treatment, the patient receives no relevant treatment, and the underlying condition progresses without intervention.
Common Misdiagnoses
Diagnostic errors typically stem from failures at one or more points in the evaluation process. Medical professionals are expected to follow a standard of care that involves taking a thorough patient history, considering a reasonable range of possible diagnoses, ordering appropriate tests, and correctly interpreting testing results. When that process breaks down due to inadequate evaluation or errors in interpreting findings, the doctor-patient relationship may be compromised in ways that can lead to a medical malpractice case.
Common contributing factors in Philadelphia misdiagnosis cases include failure to order appropriate diagnostic tests, incorrect interpretation of testing results, failure to account for the patient’s medical history or reported symptoms, inadequate follow-up when initial results are inconclusive, and failure to refer the patient to a specialist when the presentation warrants it.
Most Commonly Misdiagnosed Conditions in Philadelphia
Certain conditions are more frequently involved in misdiagnosis cases than others. Some present with symptoms that overlap with less serious illnesses, while still others are statistically uncommon in certain patient populations, leading medical professionals to overlook them. Conditions that commonly appear in medical misdiagnosis cases include:
- Cancer (including breast, colon, cervical, prostate, and melanoma)
- Fetal distress
- Heart attack and cardiovascular disease
- Stroke
- Pulmonary embolism (blood clot in the lungs)
- Bacterial meningitis
- Infections, including sepsis
- Multiple sclerosis
- Diabetes
- Lyme disease
- Appendicitis
- Depression and other psychiatric conditions
- Parkinson’s disease
When Does a Misdiagnosis Become Medical Malpractice in Philadelphia?
While medical malpractice does happen, some conditions are genuinely difficult to diagnose, and a doctor may reach an incorrect conclusion despite following appropriate standards of care. A medical misdiagnosis becomes a potential medical malpractice claim when the error resulted from a departure from the standard of care, meaning doctors failed to do what a reasonably competent medical professional would have done under the same circumstances.
In a Philadelphia misdiagnosis case, establishing malpractice requires showing that a doctor-patient relationship existed, that the doctor deviated from accepted standards of care in the diagnostic process, and that this deviation caused measurable harm to the patient. The question is not just whether the diagnosis was wrong, but whether the process by which the doctor reached that conclusion was unreasonable.
Who Can Be Held Liable for a Misdiagnosis?
Liability in a misdiagnosis case may extend beyond the treating physician. Depending on the circumstances, potentially responsible parties could include the attending or primary care physician, specialists who were consulted or who should have been consulted, radiologists or pathologists who interpreted testing results, nurses and other clinical staff involved in the evaluation, and the hospital or medical facility where care was provided. Identifying all parties whose conduct may have contributed to the error is an important part of evaluating a medical malpractice claim.
What Compensation Can You Recover in a Philadelphia Misdiagnosis Case?
The damages recoverable in a Philadelphia misdiagnosis lawsuit depend on the specific facts and circumstances of the case. Compensation may include costs of additional medical treatment made necessary by the misdiagnosis, lost wages and lost earning capacity, pain and suffering, and emotional distress. Where a misdiagnosis contributed to a patient’s death, surviving family members may have a wrongful death claim. Each case is fact-specific, and outcomes of personal injury matters depend on the circumstances involved.
Kline & Specter has handled many misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis matters resulting in significant verdicts and settlements. These include:
- A $33.1 million verdict in a breast cancer delayed diagnosis case in which a paperwork error allowed the cancer to go undetected and spread
- A $20 million award on behalf of a child who lost his sight after a curable retinal condition was not treated
- A $10.1 million verdict following a delayed diagnosis of bacterial meningitis at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia
- A $7.4 million award to a patient who suffered a crippling stroke after symptoms went unaddressed
Additional multi-million dollar verdicts in cases involving missed and misread diagnoses
Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes in future cases.
What to Do If You Believe You Were Misdiagnosed
If you suspect a diagnostic error affected your care or a family member’s care, a few simple steps can help preserve your options. Seeking a second opinion from another physician can help clarify the correct diagnosis and establish a record of the error. Obtaining copies of your medical records, including test orders, imaging, lab results, and clinical notes, may also be important, since these documents are critical for evaluating any potential medical malpractice case.
Evidence and recollections are generally clearer closer to the time of the events in question, which is a practical reason to act without unnecessary delay. Consulting with a Philadelphia misdiagnosis attorney early in the process allows for an informed assessment of whether the facts suggest a departure from the standards of care and whether a medical malpractice lawsuit may be worth pursuing.
How Long Do You Have to File a Misdiagnosis Lawsuit in Philadelphia?
Pennsylvania's statute of limitations for personal injury and wrongful death cases is usually two years from the date of (1) injury or (2) discovery of the harm and the reason for the harm. Claims involving minors may be filed until the claimant reaches age 20. There are some cases in which certain other rules apply to the statute of limitations. Given the frequent subtlety in assessing the statute of limitations and the time needed to investigate and prepare these cases, early legal consultation is advisable.
Speak With a Philadelphia Misdiagnosis Lawyer
Kline & Specter is a Philadelphia medical malpractice firm with a doctor-lawyer team that includes five attorneys who are also licensed physicians, the most in the United States. That combination of legal and medical expertise informs how the firm evaluates misdiagnosis cases and prepares each matter for trial. The firm handles cases in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, and New York, and they work with other attorneys in other states, as appropriate.
Individuals with questions about a potential Philadelphia misdiagnosis claim may contact us for a confidential evaluation.